Ask a small business owner how they found their best employee, and the answer is often a friend of a friend, a former colleague or someone’s family.
Did they plan to hire this way? It is unlikely. Most want to recruit fairly and find the best person for the job, but a vacancy rarely arrives at a convenient moment. Someone hands in their notice or a large contract comes in, the deadlines have not changed, and the owner fits interviews around the day job while the rest of the team covers the gap.
It has always been one of the hardest parts of running an SME. And when we spoke to small and medium-sized businesses across the country – as part of a new research project from the London School of Economics and Be the Business supported by JPMorganChase – they told us it is getting harder still.
The volume problem
The first problem is volume. Post a job today and 100 to 500 applications can arrive within days, many from people who have not read the advert.
AI lets candidates apply for dozens of jobs in an evening and rewrite their CV to match each advert word for word; one employer estimated seven out of ten applications now go through ChatGPT or Claude.
The quality problem
The second problem is quality. When AI writes an application, the candidate often cannot explain it. Employers described interviewees who struggled with basic questions about skills on their own CV, and some who were reading answers off their screen.
Faced with hundreds of applications which are difficult to tell apart, some employers now use AI to filter them. “AI is playing with AI,” as one put it. The result is an AI arms race that helps nobody.
The hire that falls through
The third problem comes later in the process. Even when an employer finds a strong candidate, the hire can still fall through.
Some candidates do not turn up to interviews; others accept an offer and then withdraw. One firm pays people £20 to attend an interview and still gets no-shows.
Are we seeing a generation gap in attitudes to finding work? It is easy to put this down to age, and some people blame younger people. I do not think that is fair; I think the transition from school to work has been difficult for at least the last 30 years. One events company told us the young people on its team are “amazing”; they are just harder to find.
Whatever the cause, owners are spending more time on hiring, with less confidence that the person they choose can actually do the job. So when a vacancy is urgent and every application looks the same, they take the familiar option: referrals, gut feel, a “vibe check”. It feels safer than spending days interviewing candidates who may leave before the business has recouped the cost of hiring them.
The network trap
But our networks often reflect ourselves. Rely solely on your existing network and you will only ever see a small slice of the people who could do the job.
One CEO admitted gut-feel hiring had “definitely probably made us less diverse”. In my view, a less diverse team holds back the long-term performance of the business. And the easy hire is not always the right one; a recommendation is no guarantee that someone will be better than a candidate you have never met.
The good news is that employers already know what the right hire looks like. Across all the businesses we spoke to, they described four distinct qualities: adaptability, appetite to learn, accountability and attitude. We have called them the four A’s.
Technical skills can be trained, leaders said – but the four A’s are non-negotiable. Any candidate could show those qualities, with or without a polished CV or a contact in the business. The hard part is identifying them in someone you do not know, which is why a referral always feels safer.
Changing that begins with how owners measure success. Filling a vacancy quickly feels like a win, but a hire is a long-term decision. In my view, the most important metric is how much that person helps the business grow, rather than how quickly the gap was filled.
But when the pressure is on and there is a vacancy to fill, it is easy to fall back on tried and tested routes through familiar networks. That is why we are now working on ways to make it easier for small and medium-size businesses across the country to find and assess the four As in candidates, regardless of their background or networks.
Because if this becomes easier, SMEs will be able to hire the best person for the job – and build stronger, better-performing businesses.
Key takeaways
- SME owners are increasingly falling back on personal networks to hire, not because they prefer it but because the volume and quality of open applications has become harder to manage – AI-generated applications have made it harder to identify genuine candidates from a large pool.
- The problem is not just volume: employers report that candidates who pass initial screening often cannot explain their own applications in interview, and that some candidates do not turn up to interviews or withdraw after accepting an offer, adding to the time owners spend on hiring.
- Relying on personal networks produces faster hires but narrower ones – networks tend to reflect the people who already work in a business, which limits diversity and, in the author’s view, holds back the long-term performance of the business.
- Across the businesses Be the Business spoke to, the qualities that predicted success were consistent: adaptability, appetite to learn, accountability and attitude – the four As – with technical skills seen as trainable but these four as non-negotiable.
- Measuring hiring success by how quickly a vacancy is filled is the wrong metric – a hire is a long-term decision, and the most important measure is how much that person helps the business grow.
Share via:





